Reserve Now! Pricing and availability may change.

Extra Space Storage - 4281 - Bay Shore - Howells Rd

225 Howells Road, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Rating Badge
5.0
(2)
Rating Badge
4.9
(227)
Online Move In Icon
Online Move-In AvailableRent online, skip the counter, and go straight to your space

Available Storage Units (16)

5x4

$2.55 / sqft
mini storage unit
Features
Climate ControlledUpstairs via ElevatorInterior
$51.00
$54.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

5x5

$3.20 / sqft
mini storage unit
Features
Climate Controlled1st FloorInterior
$80.00
$85.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x3

$1.83 / sqft
small storage unit
Features
Climate ControlledUpstairs via ElevatorInterior
$55.00
$59.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

5x10

$1.10 / sqft
small storage unit
Features
Climate ControlledUpstairs via ElevatorInterior
$55.00
$59.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

5x10

$1.86 / sqft
small storage unit
Features
Climate Controlled1st FloorInterior
$93.00
$99.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x5

$1.86 / sqft
small storage unit
Features
Climate Controlled1st FloorInterior
$93.00
$99.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x7

$0.93 / sqft
small storage unit
Features
Climate ControlledUpstairs via ElevatorInterior
$65.00
$69.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x8

$0.91 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Climate ControlledUpstairs via ElevatorInterior
$73.00
$77.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x8

$1.69 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Climate Controlled1st FloorInterior
$135.00
$143.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x10

$0.93 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Climate ControlledUpstairs via ElevatorInterior
$93.00
$99.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x10

$1.88 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Climate Controlled1st FloorInterior
$188.00
$200.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

9x14

$0.91 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Climate ControlledUpstairs via ElevatorInterior
$115.00
$122.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

14x10

$0.89 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Climate ControlledUpstairs via ElevatorInterior
$125.00
$133.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x14

$0.89 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Climate ControlledUpstairs via ElevatorInterior
$125.00
$133.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x15

$1.25 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Climate Controlled1st FloorInterior
$188.00
$200.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x20

$2.00 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Climate Controlled1st FloorInterior
$400.00
$410.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

Complete Amenities & Features

ACCESS

  • Electronic gate accessElectronic gate access
  • Loading dockLoading dock
  • Is your facility parking lot or driveway large enough for an 18-wheel truck?Is your facility parking lot or driveway large enough for an 18-wheel truck?

SECURITY

  • Video cameras onsiteVideo cameras onsite
  • Fenced + LightedFenced + Lighted
  • On site office at facilityOn site office at facility
  • Resident ManagerResident Manager

OFFICE HOURS
SundayClosed
Monday9:30 AM – 6:00 PM
Tuesday9:30 AM – 6:00 PM
Wednesday9:30 AM – 6:00 PM
Thursday9:30 AM – 6:00 PM
Friday9:30 AM – 6:00 PM
Saturday9:00 AM – 5:30 PM
ACCESS HOURS
Sunday6:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Monday6:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Tuesday6:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Wednesday6:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Thursday6:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Friday6:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Saturday6:00 AM – 10:00 PM

VEHICLE STORAGE REQUIREMENTS

  • Requires titleRequires title
  • Requires registrationRequires registration
  • Requires insuranceRequires insurance
  • Must be drivableMust be drivable

PROPERTY COVERAGE

  • Insurance requiredInsurance required
  • Insurance available for purchaseInsurance available for purchase
  • Protection plan requiredProtection plan required
  • Protection Plan available for purchaseProtection Plan available for purchase
  • Homeowners or renters insurance acceptedHomeowners or renters insurance accepted

PAYMENTS

  • CashCash
  • Credit cards accepted: Visa, Mastercard, AMEX, DiscoverCredit cards accepted: Visa, Mastercard, AMEX, Discover
  • CheckCheck

BILLING

  • Automatic payments availableAutomatic payments available

MISCELLANEOUS

  • Mail or packages acceptedMail or packages accepted
  • Moving supplies for saleMoving supplies for sale
  • Paperwork can be done remotelyPaperwork can be done remotely

  • Does State InspectionsDoes State Inspections
  • Has Air PumpHas Air Pump
  • Has Ice MachineHas Ice Machine

Customer Reviews

5.0(2)
Verified (2)Google (227)

Clean good team helpful employees

by William Schroder

September 3, 2025

5.0

William was professional helpful & knowledgeable. Took his time in explaining everything to us. Also was very clean & organized

Convince

by Corina Guzman

March 29, 2026

4.5

Staff is very friendly and a willing to accommodate you.

Samantha Pollucci's profileSamantha Pollucci
May 24, 2026

Had an excellent experience renting a unit at this location. Manny helped me every step of the way he even called me and let me know that I had accidentally left my unit unlocked. I finally have enough storage that I know longer need the storage unit anymore but would definitely recommend!

Zachary Milligan's profileZachary Milligan
February 6, 2026

Multiple units broken into on the night of 2/4/26. Our units lock was cut, our stuff ransacked and approximately $6k worth of stuff was stolen less than two weeks after moving in. Extra Space will direct you to file an insurance claim and absolve themselves of all responsibility. Recommend you get your own insurance that covers full replacement cost, their provided insurance only covers assessed value which means they’ll only give you the depreciated value of your belongings. Included pictures of our unit before and after the break in.

Greg Oechslin's profileGreg Oechslin
May 30, 2026

Just recently got a unit. Couldn't be happier(as Ive dealt with other Storage facilities and havent had the best experience personally). The guy who set up everything, I think it was Manny, was super helpful. Definitely will recommend!!!

Delmer Mondragon's profileDelmer Mondragon
May 13, 2026

Today I visited Extra Space Storage and Manny helped me change the size of my storage unit. As always, he was very friendly, professional, and attentive throughout the entire process. Honestly, if you want to speak with someone honest and genuinely helpful, Manny is the right person. He has helped me a lot every time I’ve needed assistance, and he always provides outstanding customer service. Very thankful for all his help and attention.

Mohamed Saleh's profileMohamed Saleh
January 24, 2026

Manny was extremely helpful with all the information required and answered all my questions with ease. Made the process very smooth and I felt secure with my belongings here. Very polite and professional. Would highly recommend these guys to anyone.

How to Rent a Storage Unit With Storage.com

There are two easy ways to secure a unit at this storage facility

1You can complete your rental process online today and go straight to your unit when you plan to move in.
2You can make a reservation today with no payment until you sign your lease at your move-in date.
How It Works
Search icon
Select your storage unit
Reserve icon
Reserve for free

Cancel or change your reservation at any time, risk-free

Move in icon
Move in